Panic Attacks vs Sensory Meltdowns

Written by J. Alex Douglas
I recently had a client reach out to me and ask for resources for reducing anxiety and the likelihood of panic attacks. She told me that her teenage son was experiencing what sounded—to her—like a panic attack, during many of his classes.
My advice to her is that it’s likely not one thing that is causing her son’s anxiety, but a buildup of many things, which culminate and come to a head during his classes… an environment where he’s already challenged to pay close attention and pressured to perform.
The first major question I would ask is: Are these episodes that he’s experiencing panic attacks, or neurological meltdowns (i.e. commonly called “autistic meltdowns”)? It could be one or the other, or he might experience both. When I was a teenager, I experienced both, but at different times and for different reasons.
For myself, the distinction was pretty clear:
Panic attacks would come somewhat out-of-the-blue and would involve an acute sense of fear, like my body was under attack from some unknown source. They included shortness of breath, a tightening sensation in my chest, and kind of a lurching sensation in my stomach (like from a sudden change of elevation). This resulted in hyperventilation—short, rapid breaths that elevated my heart rate—and the urge to clench my body up into a fetal position.
Meltdowns, on the other hand, look and feel somewhat different. They typically are preempted by a sort of ‘rising action’, where sensory and emotional stressors build up in my system, and I try to quiet or suppress my response to them, as an attempt to self-regulate. This might involve slow, deliberate breathing, clenching my jaw, tightening of my muscles as I sort of ‘clamp down’ on myself, and rapid rocking back-and-forth in my seat. The latter of which is largely recognized as an autistic tendency to self-soothe or self-stimulate (i.e. ‘stim’) as a response to stress.
Once this buildup reaches a breaking point, I might go into a full-blown meltdown, When I was younger, these meltdowns used to be more ‘quiet’ and ‘internally-focused’. I might stop breathing and then sort of ‘catch’ my breath. I might convulse or experience what are referred to as psychogenic seizures (i.e. the outward appearance of a seizure without actual epileptic activity in the brain). As I aged, my meltdowns became more vocally expressive. I might ‘snap’ at someone asking me a question—even if they’re asking how they can help—because, again, my jaw is tightened and my muscles are clenched, which tends to augment my vocal output, so that I sound angry, when I’m not feeling angry; I’m just feeling overwhelmed, frustrated with the situation, and even a bit fearful of what’s happening to me because I can’t easily control my own bodily response. I remember once screaming at a medical receptionist during a meltdown, “I’m trying to remain calm, but I’m having a meltdown and I can’t be calm, right now!! Please help me, so that I can get what I need to calm down!”
Not everyone can be that articulate. It’s common for people who are melting down to ‘elope’ (that is, flee the environment that’s causing the meltdown), yell unintelligibly, cry (again, tears don’t necessarily mean they’re feeling sad, but it’s a natural way our body sheds stress hormones), physically push away from their environment (this could include slamming books down on a desk, for example), or self-harming behavior (like thumping their head against the wall or knocking the palm of their hand against their head). It’s also common during a meltdown for the individual to engage in involuntary stimming behaviors, such as hand-wringing or flapping, rocking back-and-forth, pacing, spinning, or engaging in what may look like a ‘nervous tic’ such as rapid leg twitching or head shaking. These repetitive sensations help to ease the nervous system by relieving that pent-up muscle tension and providing neurofeedback.
Here is a Web article and a couple of YouTube videos that talk about how to tell the difference between the two:
Rula.com “Differences Between Panic Attacks and Autistic Meltdowns” https://www.rula.com/blog/autistic-meltdown-panic-attack/ This article talks about how autism, panic attacks, and meltdowns are interrelated. It discusses how to recognize one from the other, and how to manage each.
The Aspie World “Autism Meltdown vs Panic Attack (ESSENTIAL INFORMATION)”
Daniel describes his own experiences with autistic meltdowns and how this contrasts and compares to his experience of panic attacks.
ManiKMuse “Are You Having Panic Attacks or Sensory Meltdowns?”
Amanda breaks down the differences in her own lived experience between panic attacks and sensory meltdowns, and why knowing the difference between them matters. I have some additional resources I’d like to share on the topic, but it’s worth taking a moment to pause and really take stock over what’s being experienced. From there, we can better assess what advice will be most effective at addressing these concerns.
Submitted in Sincere Regard,
~J. Alex

